| | As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... | |
|
|
| Do you think the mission goals of the Iraq war were accomplished over the past 7 years? | | Yes | | 22% | [ 2 ] | | No | | 66% | [ 6 ] | | Some of them were | | 11% | [ 1 ] |
| | Total Votes : 9 | | |
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
|SaD|Peter Forum Supervision Officer

Posts: 731 Join date: 2010-06-04 Location: East Bay San Frisco
 | Subject: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Wed Sep 01, 2010 12:07 am | |
|
As some of you may have noticed recently,Iraq war news in American media has been sprucing up for a little bit more than just suicide car bombings and American war deaths.Last week President Barack Obama gave the executive order to begin the first exits of military combat divisions out of Iraq and has promised that the "mission" in Iraq will officially end today with all U.S.personell being out of the country by 2011.With this news,many military troops and their families,weary of the constant deployments overseas,apllaude the plan to end one of the costliest U.S. wars since WW2.But as our country's military operations roll to an end there several questions have been raised about the aftermath of this drastic move such as,will the Iraq government be able to keep the country together and stablized with the amount of unrest currently going on and without allied help?,what happens to U.S. servicemembers leaving Iraq?will they be sent home or redeployed to Afghanistan or other military base regions abroad?and the most prevalent.........Can the U.S. claim victory in Iraq?
Well I suppose that depends on how you look at the spectrum.On the one hand if you look at inflicted casualty counts then seeing that the U.S. and its allies have killed more than 50000 known terrorist insurgents vs 4000 casulties inflicted on our forces then yes.
But if you go deeper into the facts that:
A.No Weapons of mass destruction have been found nor used inside Iraq borders since the 2003 conflict began.
B.The insurgent movement has not been neutralized.
C.The insurgents continue to resist and cause mayhem on a daily basis
D.The Iraqi government and military is far from being capable of handling the insurgency and civil war between Shiite and Sunni factions on its own and will likely experience a situation similar to the one the Mexican government is going through with criminals after the athoritiy figures of the country instead of vice versa.
Then you would come to conclude that the answer would be unequivically no,the allies have not accomplished the mission from an objective assessment at all.
While I do feel that President Obama is making the right decision by keeping his promise to bring our troops home from a war that should have never been started in the first place,I think its fair to say that with the level of goal inconsistency,allied casualty figures and anti war sentiment,the "Iraq War"(considered a sub-operation of the larger war on terrorism) is indeed the modern day Vietnam.
In my opinion we lost more than just the war itself but the morale of our troops and the respect of the world around us.And now the question is,how do we tell this story in the history books?
|
|
 | |
|SaD|Colt.45 XBox Live Division Commander

Posts: 3658 Join date: 2010-06-04 Age: 26 Location: Chicago,IL
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sat Sep 04, 2010 7:20 pm | |
| Very good issue to be raised Pete and No I dont think the United States government came anywhere near accomplishing the goals it set out to achieve.For one thing they failed epically to prove that Sadaam's government had still obtained or planned to use WMD's after the first Gulf war (which as we already know was the purpose excuse for going into Iraq anyway),the U.S. certainly hasnt gained any freinds in the Arab world by doing so,just more enemies with more motivation to have sentiment towards us and most importantly they have been unable to halt the insurgency that continues to wreeck lives and progress in Iraq at record levels on a day to day basis.Now that Obama is finally making good on his promise to begin with drawal of our troops the question is.........now what?Where do they go to next?Afghanistan?Kuwait?South Korea?......what potential war zone will our forces stand between next on wait for a call to the next conflict that has nothing hardly at all to do with the protection of our nation lol?There ultimatley is noone to blame for the Iraq war but Bush(whom I agree with some othe rpeople,should be brought up on charges at the International War Crimes Tribunal lmao).He went in on falsified information comign from the CIA,his closest advisors and Sadaams adversaries.The entire point of that war was to free up the nations oil supply so when Saudi Arabia runs out we can suck them dry next and to halt the money being spent yearly(billions) by U.S. Air Forces to patrol the "No Fly Zone" over the country.
It is really sad the waste of human life on both the American and Iraqi side for pretty much nothing...especially not all the war was cracked up to be for. |
|
 | |
|SaD|Stryker

Posts: 175 Join date: 2010-06-13 Age: 42 Location: London baby!
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sat Sep 04, 2010 9:53 pm | |
| I have a brother in law over there right now,so for me this strikes a chord.I blame all the political hoopla bullshit carried on from the last idiot in office(Tony Blair) for what our military has become over there in Iraq in recent years.......walking targets for terrorists.
They dont have the proper armor or vehicles and arent over there for the right reasons.And they need to stop toying get some REAL amounts of troops on the ground in Afghanistan and crush those Taliban assholes to the point where they go diving back into their holes like they did in 02'.
Last edited by Stryker on Mon Sep 06, 2010 10:55 pm; edited 2 times in total |
|
 | |
IronMan64

Posts: 521 Join date: 2010-06-05 Age: 28 Location: Germany
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sat Sep 04, 2010 10:19 pm | |
| Here in Germany it is known as "The War that should have never been fought".But then again our society would be more than a bit hipocritical if we focused all of our criticism on the American government about such issues given our unfortunete past. |
|
 | |
Stick

Posts: 241 Join date: 2010-06-10 Age: 20 Location: Staak,Poland
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sat Sep 04, 2010 11:35 pm | |
| Well..when you think on it objectively both yes and no.
The United States government fronted(as we all know) that it was Chemical Weapons that they were worried about falling into the hands of Islamists though their real goal was to rid of Saddaam and his two sons so they could be replaced with a more agreeable dictatorship.And that is exactly what happened.
On the other hand the U.S. wanted to come off as the "freedom fighters" and salvationists of the middleeast.That certainly was not accomplished.
Some people also make the argument that oil played a factor,but I dont know if it did or not because the Americans havent been so hasty to touch the desert juice from there after 7 years.Maybe they are scared of their hainous plot all along actually getting found out...maybe. |
|
 | |
|SaD|Lillian Senior Cheif of Staff Operations

Posts: 1282 Join date: 2010-06-06 Age: 25 Location: Phoenix,Arizona Home sweeet home!
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Mon Sep 06, 2010 9:38 pm | |
| | IronMan64 wrote: | | Here in Germany it is known as "The War that should have never been fought".But then again our society would be more than a bit hipocritical if we focused all of our criticism on the American government about such issues given our unfortunete past. | Kind of a bad comparison for making an example but the Nazi's and the U.S. government under mostly Republican administrations made the same exact mistake of trying to bite off more foreign territory then it could chew for personal gain and advantage.
You cannot fight and control the entire world.And its very hard to submit a people which within there are fanatics willing to kill themselves just to harm or kill you(their adversaries).
Rumsfeld and Bush mistakenly thought that both Afghanistan and Iraq would be an easy "walk in and extract" mission but what they didnt understand was that after the initial bombardment of "Shock and Awe" thats when the remaining insurgents come back out of their hiding spots to try and jump you as you walk away from what you THINK is a victory.
Iraq is going to be a disaster in a couple of years and another Islamist state and Afghanistan i fear will be once again over run and ruled by the Taliban once the U.S. leaves there as well. |
|
 | |
IronMan64

Posts: 521 Join date: 2010-06-05 Age: 28 Location: Germany
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Wed Sep 08, 2010 12:43 am | |
| | Lemon Chick wrote: | | IronMan64 wrote: | | Here in Germany it is known as "The War that should have never been fought".But then again our society would be more than a bit hipocritical if we focused all of our criticism on the American government about such issues given our unfortunete past. | Kind of a bad comparison for making an example but the Nazi's and the U.S. government under mostly Republican administrations made the same exact mistake of trying to bite off more foreign territory then it could chew for personal gain and advantage.
You cannot fight and control the entire world.And its very hard to submit a people which within there are fanatics willing to kill themselves just to harm or kill you(their adversaries).
Rumsfeld and Bush mistakenly thought that both Afghanistan and Iraq would be an easy "walk in and extract" mission but what they didnt understand was that after the initial bombardment of "Shock and Awe" thats when the remaining insurgents come back out of their hiding spots to try and jump you as you walk away from what you THINK is a victory.
Iraq is going to be a disaster in a couple of years and another Islamist state and Afghanistan i fear will be once again over run and ruled by the Taliban once the U.S. leaves there as well. | Actually,the first mistake the Nazi's made was putting Adolph Hitler in control of their labor party after his failed coupe attempt.
What many outsiders dont know is that originally the Nazi Organization was a labor union with no political ties to Germany's hierarchy and their popularity and membership grew out of general feeling of most unemployed German's living in post WW1 era Germany during the European Depression.
As they gained power and influence they had no choice but to become political and apply to run for several important positions in parliment and throughout the government.By the time Hitler was elected Chanchellor in 1936 the entire mood of the German people has shifted from hoplessness to anger and seek for reperation as Hitler gave them something or someone to blame their troubles on........the Jews.
Your government however simply told half truth or full lies to sell an attitude to Americans inorder to justify and start a war with very little resistance or opposition.
Both models of manipulation are bad but I was merely bringing up the differences as opposed to comparisons betweent he two. |
|
 | |
|SaD|Evan

Posts: 290 Join date: 2010-06-08 Age: 17 Location: Tampa,Florida
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:11 am | |
| Well I mean we stopped terrorism didnt we? |
|
 | |
|SaD|Peter Forum Supervision Officer

Posts: 731 Join date: 2010-06-04 Location: East Bay San Frisco
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sat Sep 11, 2010 6:57 pm | |
| | IronMan64 wrote: | | Here in Germany it is known as "The War that should have never been fought".But then again our society would be more than a bit hipocritical if we focused all of our criticism on the American government about such issues given our unfortunete past. | Yes Ironman.We Americans unfortunetly have a bad habit of fighting and or being involved in those types of wars.
Korea,Somalia and Vietnam were 3 other good examples |
|
 | |
|SaD|Peter Forum Supervision Officer

Posts: 731 Join date: 2010-06-04 Location: East Bay San Frisco
 | |
 | |
|SaD|Colt.45 XBox Live Division Commander

Posts: 3658 Join date: 2010-06-04 Age: 26 Location: Chicago,IL
 | |
 | |
|SaD|Stryker

Posts: 175 Join date: 2010-06-13 Age: 42 Location: London baby!
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sun Sep 19, 2010 11:12 am | |
| | Quote: | | Actually,the first mistake the Nazi's made was putting Adolph Hitler in control of their labor party after his failed coupe attempt. | Agreed.
There are some people including myself that are of the exact opinion that had Hitler not declared war on and invaded Western Europe and Russia,Germany would have recovered from the European Depression within a few years,revived its economy and become the world's first Super Power while the Americans stood idlely by.It was because the Germs listen to that nutty idiot that they lost that oppurtunity. |
|
 | |
|SaD|Cabanaboy101

Posts: 521 Join date: 2010-06-05 Age: 23 Location: Holland!
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sun Sep 19, 2010 2:31 pm | |
| | IronMan64 wrote: | | Here in Germany it is known as "The War that should have never been fought".But then again our society would be more than a bit hipocritical if we focused all of our criticism on the American government about such issues given our unfortunete past. | haha thats funny Ironman because we have pretty much the same phrase for it here in Holland .
Its a small world after all. |
|
 | |
|SaD|Peter Forum Supervision Officer

Posts: 731 Join date: 2010-06-04 Location: East Bay San Frisco
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Sun Sep 19, 2010 5:32 pm | |
| | MR.THUG.45 wrote: | | Peter wrote: | | Stick wrote: | Well..when you think on it objectively both yes and no.
The United States government fronted(as we all know) that it was Chemical Weapons that they were worried about falling into the hands of Islamists though their real goal was to rid of Saddaam and his two sons so they could be replaced with a more agreeable dictatorship.And that is exactly what happened.
On the other hand the U.S. wanted to come off as the "freedom fighters" and salvationists of the middleeast.That certainly was not accomplished.
Some people also make the argument that oil played a factor,but I dont know if it did or not because the Americans havent been so hasty to touch the desert juice from there after 7 years.Maybe they are scared of their hainous plot all along actually getting found out...maybe. | Yes I think you are right Stick,It also had alot to do with the patrolling of the "No Fly Zone" on both borders of Iraq,it took so much of our money and the Pentagon budget to look pretty doing that at a time when we were at war with terrorists,so they needed to free our forces up from that obligation.I mean we couldnt just walk away and leave Kuwait hanging like the CIA did in the Bay of Pigs lol.What would we look like?
And yes,the invasion of Iraq definetly had something to do with the rich oil reserves of Iraq.Just ask Dick Cheney and his buddies at Haliburton | Lol yea Pete my dad used to say that all the time; that it was the money being burnt trying to police the air space around Iraq that was one of the major causes of the war.
Another thing he brung up which I think hasnt been looked into but is a legitimate point is that in the early 2000's Sadaam's deledgation went before OPEC and suggested that since most of the oil rich nations fell on Arabian controlled territories that oil should sold through Arabian currency instead of the American dollar.
Since the U.S. has pursuaded OPEC members to use the dollar in ALL oil trades worldwide between any nation since the Nixon administration,this sudden and dramatic shift in currency change would break the grip that the U.S. would have on the industry and possibly cause an epic collapse of our monetary system quicker then the recession we are currently in.And it all makes since cause if the world uses mostly dollars in 80% of all foreign trade then all the U.S> needs to do is keep printing paper bills in order to keep its staturs as a super power and everyone else dependant on us.
I think they silences Sadaam quickly,not only by over throwing him but handing him over to the Iraqi courts instead of the Hague where he would have had a fair trial.They knew the Irai justice system would have been totally biased and his execution was almost certain this way they could end him and any information he might have had about Iraq's relationship with the CIA in the 80's with out having to kill him themselves. | Hmm colt,yea actually I have heard something like that a few years ago when talking on the subject with a freind that had once worked in the Pentagon many years ago.That would be an interesting concept if it were indeed true that it was over the use of the American dollar for oil trades,but it would not be surprising.Our government has been back of the woods so to speak about of lot of things since the begginning of the Cold War.
I mean Im not trying to sound anti authoritarian or right winged because Im not,bt we all know and I think knew from the start that this never did have anything to do with any real threat that Saddaam and Iraq posed on our national security.Saddaam wouldnt have been stupid enough because he feared such a thing as the Iraq War would happen if he did. |
|
 | |
|SaD|Colt.45 XBox Live Division Commander

Posts: 3658 Join date: 2010-06-04 Age: 26 Location: Chicago,IL
 | Subject: Re: As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... Wed Sep 22, 2010 12:14 am | |
| | Quote: | | I mean Im not trying to sound anti authoritarian or right winged because Im not,bt we all know and I think knew from the start that this never did have anything to do with any real threat that Saddaam and Iraq posed on our national security.Saddaam wouldnt have been stupid enough because he feared such a thing as the Iraq War would happen if he did. | Nah man,no doubt,your on the right track.
And yea ofcourse most people with brains in their heads knew that the WMD's ploy was just a crock of shit excuse to go in there because they knew the U.N. inspectors wouldnt find anything because there hardly was any left(what ever chemicals Saddaam did have he used on Iraq, the Kurds and U.S. forces in the first Desert Storm).They knew that they could play the "O well he's hiding it" nutroll and they knew with 9/11 being fresh in everyone's mind and the new policies on terrorism,the American public wouldnt initially put up too much of a fuss about invading a soverign country run by a CIA spawned thug anyway rofl.
And yea I agee,Saddaam,just like the Soviets,Castro and Kim Jong IL arent stupid enough to make the same mistake that Japan did during WW2 and awake the sleeping giant lmao. |
|
 | |
| | As U.S.Troops withdraw from Iraq the Question is raised:Did the United States win the war?... | |
|